The start of college football season is less than two weeks away, anyone excited? I know we are here in Oregon – with a little someone named LSU for our first game. There are other intriguing matchups early on in the year as well, Oklahoma versus Florida State and Georgia versus Boise State come to mind. With the season so close to kick off, it’s fitting we’re getting our first glimpse at the (meaningless) preseason polls; both from the AP and the coaches. So I figured, what the heck – here is the Dirt’s preseason Top 25. I’ll show you the AP and Coaches poll so you can see where my opinion differs, to see if you agree or disagree with the Dirt.
An important reminder, the last team to begin the season ranked #1 in preseason polls to win a national title was 2004 USC, though that trophy was taken away (cough, Reggie Bush, cough). So take these rankings with a grain of salt, and at the end of the year I’ll look back to compare to see who knew what in the world they were talking about. Enjoy!
| Rank | The Dirt Poll | AP Top 25 | Coaches Poll |
| #1 | Alabama | Oklahoma (36) | Oklahoma (42) |
| #2 | Oregon | Alabama (17) | Alabama (13) |
| #3 | LSU | Oregon (2) | Oregon (2) |
| #4 | Oklahoma | LSU (1) | LSU (2) |
| #5 | Stanford | Boise State (2) | Florida State |
| #6 | Wisconsin | Florida State | Stanford |
| #7 | South Carolina | Stanford | Boise State |
| #8 | Florida State | Texas A+M | Oklahoma State |
| #9 | Texas A+M | Oklahoma State | Texas A+M |
| #10 | Virginia Tech | Nebraska | Wisconsin |
| #11 | Nebraska | Wisconsin | Nebraska |
| #12 | Arkansas | South Carolina | South Carolina |
| #13 | Oklahoma State | Virginia Tech | Virginia Tech |
| #14 | Boise State | TCU | Arkansas |
| #15 | West Virginia | Arkansas | TCU |
| #16 | Mississippi State | Notre Dame | Ohio State |
| #17 | Notre Dame | Michigan State | Michigan State |
| #18 | USC | Ohio State | Notre Dame |
| #19 | Georgia | Georgia | Auburn |
| #20 | Arizona State | Mississippi State | Mississippi State |
| #21 | Michigan State | Missouri | Missouri |
| #22 | Florida | Florida | Georgia |
| #23 | Utah | Auburn | Florida |
| #24 | Auburn | West Virginia | Texas |
| #25 | Texas | USC | Penn State |
| #* 26 | Missouri | Texas | Arizona State |
| #* 27 | Penn State | Penn State | West Virginia |
| #* 28 | Ohio State | Arizona State | Utah |
Some notes: Everyone and their mother seems to believe Oklahoma is the clear cut preseason #1 team going into the season, but they have the undesirable stench of overrated to me. In my opinion, the SEC has won 5 consecutive National Titles; so shouldn’t the SEC front-runner be preseason #1? That is what caused me to jump Alabama to #1. Sliding Oregon and LSU up a spot each was easy; and of course a lot will be determined after their September 3rd showdown in Dallas. As for Oklahoma, they can make a statement to the Dirt Poll if they win at Florida State early in the year. I also slid Stanford up a few slots to round out the top 5; heck, with Andrew Luck, how can the Cardinal not be in the top 5?
Wisconsin is another team that intrigues me, the transferring of Russell Wilson could be huge and I think the Big 10 is up for grabs now that Ohio State has been diminished greatly by off-field incidents. South Carolina goes in that category as well, which is why I climbed them up my poll. Freshman sensation Marcus Lattimore returns for his sophomore season (watch out for his Heisman talk as the year goes along) and he is joined by veteran QB Stephen Garcia and #1 overall recruit Jadaveon Clowney; which equals the Gamecocks having a big year. I dropped Florida State a peg or two, while I kept Texas A+M about the same. To round out the top 10, I pushed Virginia Tech up; with Miami out of the picture in the ACC, the Hokies are a team you can never forget about.
Nebraska should have a good year in their inaugural Big 10 season; and look for Arkansas to pick up right where Ryan Mallet left them, though I don’t expect a return to a BCS game. Both Oklahoma State and Boise State also seem overrated to me, but if the Broncos are able to handle Georgia early on – don’t be surprised if we have to listen to the BCS busters talk all season long. West Virginia rounds out my top 15, and they’re another team I think will surprise people this year. The Big East is dreadful (hint, Connecticut to the Fiesta Bowl last season); so I think they could easily go 9-3, or 10-2.
Mississippi State is one of those SEC teams who play four ‘Baylor School for the Blind’ teams in their preseason games, so a 4-4 or 5-3 conference record gives them 8 or 9 wins. I’m not too sure about Notre Dame; it seems people yearn to rank them back in the Top 25 every season. But a strong finish and whipping of Miami in the Sun Bowl last season has me intrigued. USC is a team that should be in everyone’s Top 25; they will be playing in the weak Pac 12 South division and with Matt Barkley back for his 3rd year as a starter, they can win a lot of games this year (and not go to a bowl game, of course). Georgia always has stockpiled talent, but can never seem to put the pieces together. Aaron Murray showed promise last year at QB, and if they can get over losing A.J. Green they could have a good year. Arizona State finalizes my top 20 and I think they are the default winners of the Pac 12 South this year. An early on matchup with Wisconsin has Sun Devil fans licking their fingers.
Michigan State, Florida, Utah, Auburn and Texas are the final teams to make the top 25 cut in the Dirt Poll. The Spartans had a WAY overrated season last year (which showed in a 50 point loss to Alabama in the Outback bowl). It will be interesting to see how Florida will perform under new head coach Will Muschamp; and to see if they can find a QB who could fill one of Tim Tebow’s shoes. Utah will get their first shot in a new, tougher conference. Returning QB Jordan Wynn has a lot of talent, so stay tuned to see if they can handle playing an actual game every Saturday. I couldn’t leave Auburn out of the top 25, heck they won the National Title last year. But losing their ‘Superman’ Cam Newton will be tough; extremely tough, to cope with. And finally, what would a preseason poll be without Texas? They debut their own national TV network this fall, and something is telling me Mack Browns’ Longhorns won’t miss another bowl game this season.
Just missing the cut were Missouri, Penn State and Ohio State. Missouri will have to deal with losing golden haired, golden armed Blaine Gabbert; which won’t be easy. I had to stick Penn State in there, how can you not mention the 190 year old Joe Pa’s team? And last but certainly not least, Ohio State. Did anyone else spit up their cheerios when they saw both the coaches and AP put the Buckeyes in their top 20? Are you kidding me? I had to stick them at #28 just so I could rant a little. No Terrelle Pryor (any Duck fans thanking their lucky stars he didn’t come to Oregon?), a freshman and interim head coach, and the mood around the program stinking like garbage? I say – no sweater vest roaming the sideline, no more than 8 wins this year; at best!
Well that wraps it up, hope you enjoyed the first ever Dirt preseason poll; and hope you didn’t think, ‘what an idiot’ when you peeped the rankings. Should be an exciting, dramatic and entertaining college football season; and I know I can’t wait until it starts! What about you?